Spiced Lentil & Seitan Balls

Unfortunately, despite every recipe that I've tried in this app being a huge hit, this one fell off the mark. The end result was far too oily (excessively so) and the inside wasn't properly cooked, more wet and mushy. I read the reviews after which mentioned a baking method, I wish I'd seen sooner.

PUL Team - Feb. 1, 2026, 7:44 p.m.

Heyy Roshni, aw we’re sad this one didn’t work out for you. If you ever feel like giving it another go, it really helps to make sure the lentils are very well drained, even patted dry, and to pulse the mixture just until combined, since over-mixing can trap moisture and lead to a gummy or wet middle. Shaping slightly smaller balls also helps them cook through more evenly. Thanks so much for the honest feedback, it really helps us improve 🤗

Reply

Although the batter was a bit to moist in the beginning (I assume because I used canned lentils), these came out perfectly delicious. Even my non vegan friends where impressed by both, the taste and the meaty texture, when I brought them to our New Year’s Dinner. Will definitely be making them again. Thanks for the recipe.

I think water should not be added in batter. It created lot of moisture

PUL Team - Dec. 26, 2025, 7:12 p.m.

Hi Kasturi, thanks for sharing your experience! The water in the batter is there to help the lentils blend smoothly and bind with the other ingredients. Depending on the type of lentils and how much they’ve absorbed during cooking, it could make the mixture a teeny bit wetter than expected. If you found it too moist, you can reduce the water slightly or add a bit more vital wheat gluten or breadcrumbs to help the batter hold together better. Happy cooking!👩‍🍳

Reply

Ooookay that was delicious! Easy to make and yummy! I baked them as other people suggested, for 35 min at 200°C, and it was perfect, crunchy outside and soft inside! I have frozen half for later (froze them before baking, I'll come back here to let you know if putting them straight in the oven from frozen works!)

PUL Team - Nov. 15, 2025, 12:58 a.m.

Woop woop! Thanks for trying the recipe and sharing the insight, Nohya 🤗

nohya Amande - Dec. 7, 2025, 1:30 a.m.

So I tried to de-freeze them! It worked, but the balls got more dry, I preferred the fresh ones! Plus to be honest it's so easy to make, so fresh it will be from now on!

Reply

I LOVE the flavors in the balls as well as the chimichuri 😍 First time I made these, I panfried them as mentioned in the instructions, but the inside was still very wet and soft. Not cooked through. Next time I baked them, because I read that in the comments, and that worked so much better! Will for sure make them more often 🤤
So, yeah, 4/5 ⭐️ for pan frying, 5/5 when baked.

Super flavourful! I had to bake them in a cast iron pan instead of frying them because they kept sticking to my pan but baking them turned out perfect🙂

Wow, these came out so good. Better than any I've bought from the store.
I baked them in the oven for about 35 mins.
I would love some suggestions for other flavour variations since these will go in the weekly rotation.
Amazing recipe! ♥️

PUL Team - Aug. 13, 2025, 8:42 p.m.

Heyyy Ioana! So happy to hear you enjoyed them ☺️ Hmm for flavour variations, perhaps you could try Italian herbs with marinara, smoky chipotle with salsa, or fresh dill and lemon for a Mediterranean vibe. Let us know if you test out any! ✨

Reply

So good! Yesterday I tried frying half of these in a pan, but even though they tasted good, they didn't fully cook through. So today I decided to bake the other half in the oven with a bit of oil at 200°C (top and bottom heat) for 30 minutes, flipping halfway through. They turned out perfectly crispy and chewy. Best "meatballs" I've ever made. So if anyone is having problems with this one, I really recommend the oven method.

Sadly, this recipe turned out really gummy for me. I made sure not to over mix the vital gluten flour and I cooked each ball until it was crispy on the outside. But when I ate this, the center of each ball was so gummy I couldn’t even eat them. I really love the recipes on this app so this was my first miss here.

PUL Team - May 25, 2025, 4:41 a.m.

Sorry to hear they turned out gummy inside, Jun. The texture is meant to be chewy, but definitely not overly gummy. We’ve taken your feedback to heart and made a couple updates to the directions: 1) we now say pulse instead of blend, since even a little extra mixing can make the texture too dense, and 2) we added a short resting step before shaping, which helps the gluten relax and makes the texture less gummy.

Since you already made sure not to overmix (which is great!), another thing to check is the amount of wheat gluten used. If possible, weighing it (rather than using cups) gives the most accurate result. If using cup, try spooning it in lightly and leveling it off without packing it down. Another thing to keep in mind is pan temperature. If the pan gets too hot, the outside might brown before the inside has a chance to fully firm up. Lowering the heat a bit can help it cook more evenly.

Thanks again for your thoughtful comment - it really helps us improve! <3

Jun Yi - June 3, 2025, 8:02 p.m.

Thanks for listening to my feedback!

I actually halved the size of the balls and then breaded the outside which really helped with the gummy texture. Next time I’ll try reducing the amount of wheat gluten and weighing it instead of using the measuring cups. The flavor profile of this was still delicious so once I figure out the texture, I’m sure it will be a winner.

Reply

So delicious and actually easy to make. I also baked them and they turned out great. They seemed a little underdone in the center but tasted very good and the outside was crispy. I baked them for about 25 minutes in the fan assisted setting at 200 degrees Celsius.
I served them with rice, a yogurt sauce and a salad with tomato, cucumber and parsley. So delicious and healthy too 🥰

Mine turned out great and not gummy. Maybe it depends on the vital gluten brand?
Served them with roasted bell peppers and tatziki and sourdough bread on the side :)

Margarita Kuzina - April 28, 2025, 5:55 p.m.

And i made them in the air fryer! Worked well

PUL Team - April 28, 2025, 9:22 p.m.

So glad to hear they turned out great for you, Margarita! It could vary depending on the brand of vital wheat gluten. Your pairing with roasted peppers, tzatziki, and sourdough sounds amazing 🤌

Reply

Wondering if baking would work as well?

PUL Team - April 18, 2025, 11:38 p.m.

Hey Ania! We haven’t had a chance to try baking them ourselves yet, but Caramella did leave a lovely review after baking them 🤗

Reply

Made these with urad daal and used herbes de Provence, and these are delicious as a fake meat alternative that is budget friendly and kid friendly. Would like to make the original recipe but my kids can't handle heat.

PUL Team - April 4, 2025, 4:23 a.m.

Ooo what a lovely idea, Erica, thanks for sharing the twist 🤗

Reply

This was an absolute banger and will definitely be a staple in this house hold. I'd compare the consistency of the balls to falafel but smooth - I wouldn't call it doughy but definitely not meatball-like.

I have made this several times and it is delicious and also really easy to make. Even my non vegan partner loves it! Thank you!

oh this was very good, the meatballs are really good for meal prep and can be dded to a lot of dishes

I really like the texture of seitan but the gumminess of this was next level. I am very confident I did not over mix, but I do recommend cooking this longer than 5-7 mins, and maybe even making smaller balls. Not my favourite and won’t make again but it was different!

PUL Team - March 1, 2025, 5:07 p.m.

Thanks for sharing your experience, Sonya! Cooking them longer and making smaller portions could definitely help with the texture. We hope you enjoy our other recipes more 🫶

Reply

Me gustó la combinación de las albohondigas con el chimichurri. Cocinar las albohondigas fue algo complicado para mi, porque por dentro siempre se sentían chiclosas. No creo que repita esta receta

I love this recipe. The seitan balls were nice, only I think I over mixed the dough a little bit. The sauce made this dish amazing! Definitely something I will make again :)

This dish felt so fresh and summery!
I did a few tweaks and was super happy with the result. I baked the balls and sprayed them with sunflower oil to keep them lower in fat. They turned out not chewy at all which was perfect.
I also added less olive oil to the sauce and it worked well.
I paired it with quinoa 😋

PUL Team - Jan. 13, 2025, 6:21 p.m.

Thanks a bunch for taking the time to share your experience with the recipe, Caramella! Love the idea of pairing it was quinoa as well.

Reply

Is this supposed to be soft and squishy inside or did I possibly overmix or not cook enough? I replaced the brown lentils with black Beluga lentils.
Love

PUL Team - Jan. 7, 2025, 6:24 p.m.

Hey Palmchord, the texture inside should be soft and tender, but if it’s too squishy, it could be due to overmixing or not enough cooking time. It's best to weigh the gluten, or if using cup measures, to gently spoon and level to ensure it's not overpacked. Black Beluga lentils might also contribute a slightly different texture, but we also recommend using the same weight as the lentils they replace and not a direct cup to cup substitution 🤗

Reply

I was really excited about this recipe, but I don't have Vital Wheat in my area. I used Almond flour instead and it was an epic fail. The balls were very sticky and fell apart into a sludgy mess while cooking in the oil.

PUL Team - Jan. 5, 2025, 12:58 a.m.

Hey Michael, aw thank you for sharing your experience. Almond flour can’t replace vital wheat gluten in this recipe because it lacks the gluten needed to provide structure and elasticity. Gluten forms a stretchy matrix that holds the balls together whereas almond flour doesn’t have these binding properties, resulting in a sticky, crumbly texture. If it helps, we ordered our vital wheat gluten online 🙂

Reply

Nope, not for me. The texture was horrible. Too chewy. Couldn’t eat it. I don’t like the homemade seitan for the same reason so this was probably always going to be a non-starter for me😂. BUT I absolutely loved the chimichuri sauce with yoghurt and ate that instead 😋
The lentil spice mixture was delicious 👍

PUL Team - Jan. 5, 2025, 2:45 a.m.

Hey Louise, sorry to hear the texture wasn’t for you. This one definitely resembles the homemade seitan. We're glad you enjoyed the chimichurri sauce with yogurt though, and hope you enjoy our other recipes more!

Reply

Much appreciated dish, especially the combination with the chimichurri sauce….mmmmm!
I added a vegetable tomato sauce and rice to make it a full main course. The kids loved it.

So delicious! So quick to make too, I used an air fryer and it made it so easy

Insanely good! It's perfect. I feel like I'm eating at a restaurant. Thanks a lot!

Absolutely scrumptious! Warm, spiced, and fairly simple to make.