Classic Potato Salad

Wowowow this potato salad is perfection. Ten times better than the store bought stuff. Super creamy even though there wasn't a huge amount of mayo. This is going to be made every sunny throughout the summer. Thanks for the delicious recipe, highly appreciated 🥰

PUL Team - May 28, 2025, 10:04 p.m.

Yayy so thrilled to hear that the potato salad recipe is being enjoyed, Tina, it means the world!❣️

Fantastic taste, spectacular potato salad! Try this one!

The paprika make it taste so good

Very nice dressing

Très bon ! J'avais peur qu'il y ait trop de céleri mais c'était parfait. Je n'aime pas trop l'aneth "tout seul", j'ai mis du persil.

Loved this one! Quick and super easy!

This is so flavorful. Easy to make. It is a keeper for sure.

Absolutely delicious!!!

Fantastic! Go with the weight measurements instead of the measuring cups.

Fantastic recipe and a great crowd pleaser

I've made a few potato salads in the last couple of years, and this one was definitely the best. All the favors balanced perfectly!

I made this as a side to the Sloppy Joe's and it's so good! Such an easy dish and by the time the potatoes are ready, you can have everything else done. Potato salads are always a good idea 😋

PUL Team - Aug. 15, 2024, 8:07 p.m.

Woop woop! A lovely idea to pair potato salad with the sloppy joes. So happy to hear it was enjoyed, Rob 🫶

This was a hit at a picnic I made it for!

very delicious, made quickly.

I made this salad for a BBQ meeting and everyone complimented me on it!

10 stars recipe.

Easy and delicious!

Hello! I made it once around 2 months ago, was very good! Ofc no dill !
This time I wanna make it lighter- using soy organic yogurt Sojade, what should I add else to dressing, if replacing mayonnaise with it ?
Some olive oil and everything else or not ?
Thanks !;)

PUL Team - Feb. 10, 2024, 6:35 p.m.

Hey Luiza, we haven't tested it out but if you'd like to try we imagine you could use soy yogurt with a touch of olive. Perhaps try to use a neutral yogurt and add more spices to taste if needed :)

This was fantastic- I traded dill for capers because that’s what I had.

Added extra pickles because we loooove pickles but this recipe is super tasty and will do again

This was creamy, flavorful, and had a little bit of tang, so very delicious! It was a good accompaniment as a side to a hummus sandwich for lunch.

PUL Team - Dec. 2, 2023, 3:26 a.m.

We're so happy that the potato salad is being enjoyed, Danielle, thank you! 😊

I had some leftover broccoli 🥦 that needed to be used. Absolutely delicious, the vinegary mayo is delicious. I will make this more in the future. Especially now that it is summer ☀️ in the Southern hemisphere.

PUL Team - Nov. 26, 2023, 10:18 p.m.

We're so glad that the potato salad was enjoyed, Fransisca! Hugs to the Southern hemisphere 🤗 ☀️

A great recipe, I loved it, I was sceptical at first, but I'm so glad I've made it 👏🏼

It was very easy to make, but it was still tasty! First time I am trying homemade potato salad and it didn't disappoint!

Yummy 😋

Sooo tasty and easy! Love it!

Love it

Awesome! Easy and tasty

Just made it and it tastes perfect!

different taste than usual in a very good way!

This was very addictive! I kept going back for more helpings! It was a great side dish to bring over to a friend gathering we had. Subbed pickles for pickled radish and used Chinese-style mustard instead of yellow (based on what we had in the fridge).

Easy to make and so good!

SO good! Added spring onion and vegan bacon bits, perfect snack after a hike!

So good!

Added some cherry tomatoes and cold vegan bacon pieces and it was delicious

Less mayonnaise for me and instead mix in some vegan Joghurt

I grew up in Germany and every family has their own spin on a classic potato salad. I very much enjoyed this recipe (and it tasted even better the next day!). I added a splash of the pickle juice to it to make it extra tangy and added some apple pieces the next day. All in all a very easy, creamy, and delicious recipe!

Ricarda - July 5, 2023, 8:15 p.m.

Great recommendation with the pickle juice makes it even better

PUL Team - July 6, 2023, 3:11 a.m.

Woop woop! So happy to hear, Nadika - love the idea to use pickle juice too 😃

Really easy and creamy!

Love the dill and mustard combo